Christmas horror: twelve books for when you are tired of cozy

Christmas horror is older than cozy Christmas. M.R. James read ghost stories aloud at Cambridge on Christmas Eve for a reason: the longest nights of the year are what the genre was built for. These twelve are the ones that still land, grouped by what they actually do.

The holiday-set anthology and novella pile

NOS4A2 by Joe Hill. Charlie Manx drives a 1938 Rolls-Royce Wraith to Christmasland, where it is always Christmas morning and the children are not quite children any more. The horror novel that owns December for a lot of readers.

Krampus: the Yule Lord by Brom. Painted by the author, which matters once you see it. Santa as the villain, Krampus as the aggrieved underdog, set in West Virginia one Christmas Eve.

Hark! The Herald Angels Scream, edited by Christopher Golden. Eighteen stories commissioned for the collection, including Joe Hill, Seanan McGuire and Josh Malerman. The uneven one on the list, which is also what makes anthologies work: the best three in here beat anything else in print for the length.

Dolly by Susan Hill. A novella from the author of The Woman in Black. A china doll, an isolated fen house, an aunt who should not have brought the two cousins together. Reads in an evening.

The winter siege

Snow by Ronald Malfi. A blizzard strands travellers at a highway town where something is coming down with the snow. Bleak, fast, mid-2000s mass-market horror done well.

The Winter People by Jennifer McMahon. Vermont, two timelines a century apart, a journal buried in the wall, a Sleeper. Less jump-scare than slow-dread, which some readers want from a winter book.

The Shining by Stephen King. The hotel, the snow, the father. Already on everyone's shelf for a reason; the reread in December is the point.

Dark Matter by Michelle Paver. 1937 Arctic expedition, one man stays behind for the polar winter, the sun goes down for months. Short, cold, and the one on the list that actually keeps readers up.

The classics that invented the subgenre

A Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens. Read as a ghost story rather than a redemption fable, which it originally was. Four ghosts, a London Christmas Eve, 1843. This is the origin point and the shortest book on the list.

The Collected Ghost Stories of M.R. James. James wrote these to read aloud at King's College, Cambridge on Christmas Eve. The Mezzotint, Oh Whistle and I'll Come to You, Casting the Runes, Lost Hearts. The BBC's Ghost Story for Christmas tradition started here and still runs.

Smoke Ghost and Other Apparitions by Fritz Leiber. Title story published 1941; a smoke-grimed urban ghost haunting a Chicago office worker through winter. One of the first horror stories to understand that modern cities produce their own ghosts.

The gothic outlier

White Is for Witching by Helen Oyeyemi. A cliff house in Dover, a mother gone, twin children, a house that refuses to let certain people leave. Not a Christmas book exactly, but the atmosphere runs cold enough to belong here, and it is the most beautifully written book on the list.

That is twelve. If you make it through all of them in a single December you will have had a different holiday than most of your friends, which is possibly the point.

One library

Where Voluta fits

Put the twelve on a list in Voluta and the same list holds the films and series they turned into, which is most of them: NOS4A2 the AMC show, The Shining the Kubrick film and the miniseries, Krampus the Michael Dougherty film, A Christmas Carol in whichever adaptation is yours. A horror reading list in December tends to want the movie night that goes with it.

Reading sessions log how long it actually took you to finish Dark Matter in one sitting. A monthly Rewind in January tells you what you read in December, which is a nice coda to a themed month. And buddy reads work well for a list like this, because horror is better shared.

What it costs

Tracking books, films, TV and games is free, along with lists, search, clubs, buddy reads, imports and the annual Rewind. Premium is $4.99 a month or $39.99 a year and adds deeper analytics, the monthly Rewind, custom themes and supporter perks.

See what Premium includes

Questions

What is the best Christmas horror book?
For a modern long novel: NOS4A2 by Joe Hill. For a short cold one: Dark Matter by Michelle Paver. For the one that started it all: the ghost stories of M.R. James. Different answers for different evenings.
Is A Christmas Carol actually horror?
It is a ghost story written and marketed as a ghost story. Dickens published it in 1843 in a tradition of Christmas ghost stories that was already a hundred years old. The redemption reading came later.
Why are ghost stories a Christmas thing?
The long nights. The English middle-class tradition of reading ghost stories by the fire at Christmas is centuries old. M.R. James formalised it in Cambridge; the BBC kept it alive with its annual Ghost Story for Christmas broadcast. Americans mostly skipped this bit when they inherited the holiday, which is why it reads as novel over here.
Are any of these not Christmas-set?
A few are winter rather than Christmas specifically. Dark Matter is Arctic autumn into polar winter. The Shining is a mountain winter. The Winter People is Vermont in February. The reading experience is what the list is organised around, not the calendar.
Where can I track this reading list?
In Voluta, make a list called Christmas Horror, add the twelve, set it as your current list, and the watchlist and finished dates update together. Open the list in December next year and most of it is still there.

Books, films, TV and games. One library.

Free to track all your media. Import what you already have.

Start tracking