Book tracker apps compared for 2027
Five book trackers get named in almost every conversation about this: Goodreads, StoryGraph, Fable, Hardcover and Voluta. They are not doing the same job, which is the thing most round-ups miss. Here is what each one is for, including this one, so you can pick the one that fits.
| Feature | The field | Voluta |
|---|---|---|
| Who owns it | Goodreads: Amazon since 2013. StoryGraph: independent, built by Nadia Odunayo. Fable: independent, venture-backed. Hardcover: independent, community-run. | Independent, built and run by a small team. No ads, no reseller skim. |
| What it tracks | Goodreads, StoryGraph and Hardcover track books. Fable tracks books, with TV and films through curated lists rather than a diary. | Books, films, TV and games on the same lists, each with its own diary. |
| Ratings | Goodreads and Fable: whole stars. StoryGraph and Hardcover: half stars. | Quarter stars, because 3.75 is sometimes the truest answer. |
| Imports | Everyone reads a Goodreads export. StoryGraph and Hardcover also read each other and Kindle. Fable reads Goodreads and Storygraph. | Goodreads, StoryGraph, Kindle, Tome and Letterboxd CSVs, plus a Trakt connection for TV and films and a Steam connection for games. |
| Discussion | Goodreads reviews and friend feeds. StoryGraph buddy reads. Fable book clubs. Hardcover comments on reviews. | Book clubs, buddy reads and watch clubs, with threads gated by how far each person actually is so nobody has to write "spoilers ahead". |
| The free line | Goodreads: free, with ads and sponsored placement. StoryGraph: free, with Plus at $4.99/mo for stats. Fable: free, with Premium at $7.99/mo for clubs. Hardcover: free, with Supporter tiers. | Free: tracking all four media, lists, clubs, buddy reads, imports and the annual Rewind. Premium: $4.99/mo for deeper analytics, the monthly Rewind, custom themes and supporter perks. |
What people are actually comparing
The question "which book tracker is best" is almost always a stand-in for something more specific. Which one does my friends use. Which one does not run on Amazon. Which one lets me rate in half stars. Which one will not lose my data when it sells. The lists that answer "best" without knowing which of those matters end up recommending Goodreads to someone who left Goodreads for a reason.
The five below are grouped by what they are actually for, not by which one has the shiniest marketing site. If one of them sounds like what you meant, that is probably your answer.
One library
Where each one fits
Goodreads is the default. The catalogue is huge, your friends are probably on it, and the data goes to Amazon. Pick it if you want the biggest community and do not mind the ads or the ownership.
- StoryGraph is the stats tracker. It is built around moods, pace and reading-season charts, and the recommendation engine is the strongest of the five if you feed it enough data. Pick it if you read a lot and want to see what you read as numbers.
- Fable is the club tracker. It runs many small clubs with celebrity hosts and a magazine-style feed. Pick it if a club is the thing you want and the feed is a feature rather than a chore.
- Hardcover is the community tracker. Independent, open roadmap, active Discord. Pick it if the vibe of the place matters as much as the features, and you want to be an early voice in what gets built.
- Voluta is the cross-media tracker. Books, films, TV and games on the same lists, with clubs and buddy reads that gate discussion by progress. Pick it if what you read, watch and play overlaps enough that you keep flipping between apps.
However you finish things
Where Voluta sits in that list, honestly
The catalogue is smaller than Goodreads, which has twenty years of head start. The community is smaller than StoryGraph, which was the first serious indie alternative. There are fewer live clubs than Fable, which runs clubs as its headline. The roadmap is less public than Hardcover, which votes on features in Discord.
- What Voluta has that the other four do not is one library for all four media, clubs and buddy reads that work on films and TV too, and spoiler-gated threads so you can discuss a book your group is reading at four different speeds without hiding anyone's progress.
- So the honest shortlist: if books are the only thing and community is the point, Goodreads or StoryGraph or Fable each have a good case. If what you track is books plus at least one other thing, Voluta is the one built for that.
What it costs
Tracking books, films, TV and games is free, along with lists, search, clubs, buddy reads, imports and the annual Rewind. Premium is $4.99 a month or $39.99 a year and adds deeper analytics, the monthly Rewind, custom themes and supporter perks.
Questions
- Which is the best book tracker in 2027?
- Depends what you mean by best. For the biggest catalogue and community: Goodreads. For the deepest stats: StoryGraph. For live book clubs: Fable. For community voice and independence: Hardcover. For tracking books alongside films, TV and games on one library: Voluta. Pick the one whose answer matches your question.
- Which book tracker is not owned by Amazon?
- Four of the five. StoryGraph, Fable, Hardcover and Voluta are independent. Goodreads is the Amazon-owned one.
- Which one has half or quarter stars?
- StoryGraph and Hardcover rate in half stars. Voluta rates in quarter stars. Goodreads and Fable are whole stars only.
- Which one imports from Goodreads?
- All four alternatives read a Goodreads export CSV. The one that gives you the most once you import is the one that also tracks the other things you want to track, which is why cross-media matters once a library has moved.
- Is it worth switching trackers at all?
- It is if the one you are on is not the one you would pick today. The import costs an evening; the twenty years of re-entering ratings you would face without one is what makes most people stay somewhere they have outgrown. If none of these sound better than what you have, that is also a fine answer.
Books, films, TV and games. One library.
Free to track all your media. Import what you already have.
Start tracking













